Siting Desk

California courts have set aside two project approvals and one moratorium since October 2025

Nine suits over where battery storage and data centers can be built, filed or decided since January 2025. Four are pending in trial court. Each row names the court and links the ruling, filing or news report it rests on, checked Nov 16, 2026.

All 9 cases

Newest court action first.

CaseWhat it challengesWhere it standsCourtSourcesFiled
Imperial Valley Computer Manufacturing v. City of ImperialDismissed, may amendImperial County, data centerImperial Data Center (IVCM)The developer says city officials stalled its site plans for data centers on city land zoned I-2 and retaliated against it, including by suing the county over its approvals. Claims: due process, equal protection, First Amendment retaliation and municipal liability.Judge Janis L. Sammartino dismissed every claim on Nov 2, 2026 and gave IVCM 30 days from docketing to file an amended complaint.About Dec 2: Deadline for IVCM to amend its federal complaint.U.S. District Court, Southern District of CaliforniaNo. 3:26-cv-00128-JLS-LROrder granting motion to dismiss, Nov 2, 2026 (PDF)Courthouse News: judge throws out IVCM's claimsJan 2026
Back Country Community Alliance for Responsible Development v. County of San DiegoPendingSan Diego County, battery storageStarlight Solar (100 MW solar, 217.4 MW / 868 MWh storage, Boulevard)The Board of Supervisors' 5-0 approval on Sept 16, 2026 of a Major Use Permit and EIR for the 588-acre project of Empire II LLC. The petition says the EIR did not disclose or mitigate battery fire and toxic plume risk (county documents gave maximum plume distances of 366 feet and 2,230 feet), evacuation or water supply.Filed 27 days after the notice of determination was posted. The project's land use consultant told KPBS the suit lacks merit and that the developer will try to settle.Jan 13, 2027: Last day for petitioners to request a hearing, 90 days after filing (Pub. Res. Code 21167.4).San Diego County Superior CourtKPBS: county and developer sued, Oct 22, 2026San Diego Union-Tribune via Fire Engineering: the petition's claimsCEQAnet: Starlight notice of determination, Sept 18, 2026Oct 15, 2026
City of Imperial v. County of Imperial (Sierra Club, intervenor)Approval set asideImperial County, data centerImperial Data Center (IVCM, about 950,000 sq ft and 330 MW, Aten and Clark roads)The county's November 2025 grading approval, the April 2026 lot merger (No. 00191) and road vacation, and its finding that the project was exempt from CEQA.Judge L. Brooks Anderholt ruled Sept 9, 2026, adopting his Aug 31 tentative decision: the county abused its discretion by approving the lot merger without CEQA review of the whole project, including its battery system, gas generators and substation, and the November 2025 grading approval is set aside. IVCM said it will move for a new trial and then appeal.Imperial County Superior CourtNo. ECU004457KPBS: court overturns the approval, Sept 9, 2026Petitioners' brief on the tentative decision, Sept 8, 2026 (PDF)KPBS: the city sues, Dec 12, 2025Dec 4, 2025
Imperial Valley Computer Manufacturing v. County of ImperialMoratorium set asideImperial County, data centerCountywide data center moratoriumThe urgency moratorium on data centers, Ord. 1616 (June 16, 2026), and its extension, Ord. 1618 (July 14, 2026).Judge Jeffrey B. Jones granted the petition Aug 21, 2026: neither ordinance found a current and immediate threat to public health, safety or welfare, as Gov. Code 65858(c) requires, so the county had to set both aside. The court refused to order how the county processes IVCM's applications. The Board adopted a new urgency moratorium 5-0 on Oct 6, 2026.Imperial County Superior CourtNo. ECU004800Tentative decision, Aug 21, 2026 (PDF)KPBS: judge poised to strike the moratorium, Aug 28, 2026KPBS: supervisors reinstate the moratorium, Oct 8, 2026June 2026
Puente Hills Community Preservation Association v. City of IndustryPendingLos Angeles County, battery storageMarici BESS (400 MW, Aypa Power, Gale Avenue, City of Industry)The city's approval and mitigated negative declaration for a 400 MW battery plant on a 9.2-acre site (notice of determination posted Feb 18, 2026). The association says the environmental review was inadequate and asks for an EIR.Judge Joel L. Lofton sustained a demurrer with 30 days to amend (reported Aug 10, 2026). The association says it filed an amended petition and that a trial setting conference was set for Nov 5, 2026; no result is posted.Los Angeles County Superior CourtDaily Journal: CEQA challenge gets a second chance, Aug 10, 2026Petitioner's case update, Aug 18, 2026CEQAnet: Marici notice of determination, Feb 18, 20262026
Imperial Valley Computer Manufacturing v. Imperial Irrigation DistrictPendingImperial County, data centerWater for the Imperial Data CenterIID's May 1, 2026 denial of IVCM's application for 880 acre-feet a year of Colorado River water for cooling, filed after recycled water deals with the cities of Imperial and El Centro fell through.No ruling found.Imperial County Superior CourtKPBS: developer sues for Colorado River water, June 15, 2026Western Water: the water fight heads to court, Aug 4, 2026IVCM's petition (PDF)June 2026
Imperial Irrigation District v. County of ImperialPendingImperial County, battery storageBig Rock 2 Cluster (Avantus, up to 500 MW solar and 500 MW storage on 1,849 acres)The Board's Dec 9, 2025 approval and EIR, which came after the Planning Commission voted unanimously against the project. IID says the review did not analyze effects on water, including inflows to the Salton Sea, the loss of farmland, or the combined effect of solar projects on more than 13,000 acres of farmed land.Filed within the 30-day CEQA limit (reported Jan 12, 2026). No ruling found. IID said it remains open to working with the county and the developer.Not stated in reportsBeyond Borders News: IID files its CEQA challenge, Jan 12, 2026KXO: IID challenges the countyImperial County: Big Rock 2 notice of determination, Dec 10, 2025 (PDF)By Jan 9, 2026
Center for Biological Diversity v. City of PittsburgSettledContra Costa County, data centerPittsburg Technology Park (data center of about 368,551 sq ft in phase 1, AVAIO)The city's approval of the Pittsburg Technology Park Specific Plan and EIR for a 76.38-acre site with a data center and two warehouses. The petition said the EIR understated greenhouse gas emissions and skipped feasible mitigation.Settled in December 2025. The owner adds rooftop solar, EV charging and a 100% carbon-free electricity program, and pays $750,000 to a foundation for climate projects.Contra Costa County Superior CourtNo. N24-2162Climate Case Chart: case summary and settlement termsSettlement papers, December 2025 (PDF)Dec 2, 2024
Save Our Rural Town v. County of Los AngelesApproval set asideLos Angeles County, battery storageHumidor BESS (Hecate Grid, now Fullmark Energy, Acton)The county's ministerial approval of a battery plant in an M-1 light manufacturing zone, which relied on a 2021 planning memo that treated battery storage like a distribution substation.Judge Curtis A. Kin granted the writ Oct 14, 2025: the zoning code does not list battery storage, so the memo could not make it an allowed use. The approval is void, and the project would need CEQA review to go forward. Appeal status not found.Los Angeles County Superior CourtDaily Journal: judge rules the county violated zoning, Oct 22, 2025The Signal: the ruling, Oct 2025Heatmap: the 2021 memo thrown out2023

The tracker lists suits whose status could be confirmed from a ruling, a filing or a news report. It leaves out fire damage claims against operating plants. Research from public records, not legal advice. How cases are found.